As my son
considers going to school at Loyola in Chicago, we’ve developed a routine. I
pretend to be horrified and say “Promise me you won’t come home Catholic and
Republican,” and Geo replies “I promise I won’t become Catholic.”
In fact, I
trust my kids to develop their own thoughtful approach to religion and
politics. We tend to think along
similar lines and have shared values when it comes to the big things. One of
those is to examine any idea that comes along carefully packaged.
Still, I’ll
admit to being irritated while listening to Wisconsin Public Radio’s show this
morning on parents “party training” their kids. One guest, psychologist
Christine Hamilton, maintained that it was a terrible thing to do. But I wondered, aren’t parents supposed to
teach their children the things they believe most deeply?
That topic,
parents teaching (or brainwashing) young children to consider themselves
members of one political party or other, is a hot one on the Net this week. Someone’s making buckets of money selling baby
onesies emblazoned with “Weepublican” and “My Mama’s for Obama.”
For once, the
Democrats have an edge on cutesy slogans. “Mom and Me for Hillary” has a nice
beat and you can sing along with it. “Romney is My Homeboy”. . . doesn’t. It’s just hard to use the name Huckabee
without sounding derisive. And McCain doesn’t only rhyme with “gain.”
Anyone who’s
taught kids knows that they are walking iPods loaded with the refrains of their
parents’ conversations. And not just the ones we want them to have. They mimic
what they hear and see. The problem is that when it comes to politics, and
maybe religion too, what they hear is not usually deep and thoughtful. More
often, it’s simplified. Especially with politics, it tends to be harsh and
rigid, dismissive of all other ideas that don’t fit into black and white
categories. Right and wrong, good and evil.
Political
rhetoric isn’t the word of God handed down on stone tablets. It’s all about
control, compromise, and manipulation. So shouldn’t we protect our kids from
it? Better yet, teach them how to deconstruct it and figure where it fits in a
greater scheme of things.
As a little kid, I eavesdroped on my parents and their friends as they watched the returns from
the Nixon-Kennedy election in 1960. It was a close battle, and when it looked
like things were going toward Kennedy, all the assembled Republicans grew
louder. “If Kennedy gets in, we’re doomed,” they said. I believed them, and I was terrified.
Of course they were wrong.
Extreme partisan statements nearly always are. Some things changed, some stayed the same, and we were not destroyed.
So I’m back
onboard with Hamilton’s idea. Little
kids shouldn’t be Republicans or Democrats. When we talk about how wonderful
things will be with President X, how terrible things will be with President Y,
we aren’t telling the truth. We are just scaring ourselves. And them.
If my kids were
little now, I’d buy them both Why Mommy is a Democrat and Help, Mom! There Are
Liberals Under My Bed. Then we’d
discuss the differences between indoctrination and education and try to figure
out what truths, if any, lie in among the simplifications and distortions.
