MyCommunityNOW.com
Blog Home |  Email Author  |  About this Blog       Welcome to MyCommunityNOW - Blogs Sign in | Join

Practically Speaking

Kyle and her husband moved to Brookfield in 1986. She became active in local politics and started blogging in 2004. Her focus is primarily on local issues but often includes state and national topics, too. Kyle looks at things from the taxpayers’ perspective in a creative, yet down to earth way, addressing them from a practical point of view.

Expelled is excellent! A+++

By Kyle Prast
Friday, Apr 25 2008, 07:42 PM

After weeks of anticipation, I went to see the movie Expelled today. It is a documentary by Ben Stein on how the scientific community routinely suppresses legitimate scientists and doctors from expressing any point of view other than that of evolution.

The full name of the movie is, Expelled, No Intelligence Allowed. It is called that because of the many scientists Ben interviewed that have been fired and blacklisted since they published papers hinting that Intelligent Design, I.D., is a valid explanation for how life began.

Despite Ben Stein being a comedic actor, he is deadly serious about this subject. He does a great job of making his series of interviews with numerous scientists and doctors from both schools of thought engaging. Old black and white movie clips from movies such as Frankenstein, Wizard of Oz and I think Inherit the Wind, as well as news clips of Hitler, the Berlin Wall, etc. are used to emphasize various points. Their inclusion makes the documentary more interesting to the viewer.

Ben visits and interviews scientists from all over the world, including the Discovery Institute, Center for Science & Culture, a think tank "challenging various aspects of evolutionary theory." The Discovery Institute is not a religious organization.

Intelligent Design is not faith based. The media and most mainstream scientists, universities, and institutions, however like to brand it as such. I admit, I was not really familiar with exactly what Intelligent Design meant. Although I.D. dove-tails with Creation Science, I.D. does not specify who or what the intelligence is. It just tries to answer the question of who or what started that first cell or created the universe.

I.D. questions evolution and Darwinism in that evolution cannot explain how the one cell began. Some evolutionary explanations defy logic. One scientist, Dr. Ruse (sp?) insisted life got started by certain molecules piggy-backing on top of crystals. (No explanation where the crystals or molecules came from.)

An I.D. Scientist countered that thinking by stating 217 proteins are needed to create life and that those 217 proteins would need to be arranged by accident 250 times in succession for life to have started. That defies logic. Therefore some intelligence had to have created it. 

Back when Darwin published his theory in 1859, little was known about the complexity of the cell. Now, thanks to modern science and sophisticated equipment, doctors and scientists are constantly amazed at how intricate each part of the cell is. The deeper they look, the more complex cellular structure and physiology is.

The real kicker came at the end of the movie. Stein again interviewed Dr. Richard Dawkins, author of The God Delusion. Dawkins is an avowed atheist and evolutionist.

Ben asks Dawkins, who created the universe and how did life start? Keep in mind Dawkins cannot accept Intelligent Design in any way, but he answers something akin to this: some other sort of life could have evolved elsewhere and it planted its seed here.

In other words, some sort of alien from another world evolved into some very intelligent being and then came here and planted that first seed of life. (No explanation of how that alien life got started.) I think Dawkins went on to say something about how it (life) couldn't have just happened all at once. (Watch for this part when you see the movie.)

To Dawkins, Alien Design is OK, Intelligent Design, not OK--even if who or what is that intelligence is not identified? 

Judeo-Christian religious beliefs and science are not polar opposites. Noteworthy scientists such as Galileo, Newton, and Kepler were all Christians. If Ben Stein, who is Jewish, has his way, men of other religions besides that of atheism and evolution will again be able to have their voices heard without fear of termination and blacklisting. 

This weekend promises to be quite awful weather wise. It might be a good time to investigate Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed for yourself. I saw it at Mayfair at their $5, 10AM showing. It is also at these theaters.  

The movie is rated PG, possibly because they showed some scenes from German death camps? 

Links: Upcoming events in Brookfield

4th Annual Weed Out, May 3rd, Mary Knoll Park

counter hit xanga

Brookfield7, Fairly Conservative, Betterbrookfield
Vicki Mckenna

 

Comments

Santa's Elf   

I was never expelled. But I was suspended so many times that I came to wonder whether I was an 'inie' or an 'outie'. So much for public education!

Where do Francis Collins' beliefs fit into your creation story? Here's a Christian scientist and geneticist who argues that God used evolution during His work of creation. That evolution was one of God's creation tools.

Is he that easy to discount?

Kyle's reply: I am not familiar with Francis Collins, but if he has the standpoint you cite, I would not personally agree. I am a literal creationist for a number of reasons. All views require faith whether they be evolution, literal creation, or somewhere in between.

Physical evidence such as the amount of moon dust, saltiness of ocean, and size of sun to name a few, point to a young earth. Evolution to even be considered needs to have a lot of time, hence the billions of years.

If one tries to fit the 6 days of creation into evolution, there are problems with that too. Example: plants were created before night and day were divided and before insects for pollinating. If a creation day is 1,000 of years, those plants won't do too well.

If you have any interest in a literal creation science point of view, Ken Ham of Answers in Genesis will be at the VCY rally on May 3. He is very engaging.

Additional thought, if Francis is speaking of natural selection, that is observable and I believe survival of the fittest to be true. 

April 25, 2008 8:02 PM

My Two Cents   

Thanks for the tip, Kyle.  We seldom go to a movie anymore because they always promote some Lefty Hollywood point of view.  I'm not wasting my money to hear more of that stuff.  I can get that on network news every night. I can already smell the popcorn!

April 26, 2008 9:22 AM

intewedm   

Kyle, I guarantee you that those who accept evolution won't bother to go the the VCY rally to hear anything that goes against their unfounded theories.  There is NO evidence for evolution.  I think it is reasonable to assume that species to "evolve" to the extent that they adapt.  For example, the Asians are getting bigger because they have better diets, but that doesn't make a monkey become a man.  A dog is and always was a dog.  Show me the fossil evidence for one species changing into another...oops, there isn't any!

Kent Hovind successfully presents EVIDENCE which clearly debunks the theory of evolution and some of his DVDs are available for viewing through the county library system.  It's quite interesting that NONE of them are at the Brookfield library.  His legal troubles should not detract from the EVIDENCE that he presents.  If viewed with an open mind, and one still believes in evolution, it can only be because one
just won't accept that there is a God.  The silly evolution theory is less than 200 years old and all the scientists prior to that time believed in God.  Man is just enamored with his own intelligence in this age but forgets where it came from....I know from "primordial slime".  How blind must one be to believe they can get something from nothing?

Kyle's reply: I saw Kent Hovind a number of years ago at Concordia College. He is terrific! Ken Ham is also great, but I have only seen him on TV. I hope to go to his Creation Museum in Kentucky some day. I have heard it is very good and not heavy handed.

You are right about the VCY rally, but some Christians who still believe in evolution might attend just to see what he is all about. 

 

April 26, 2008 11:13 AM

Waukesha Carnival « Musings of a Thoughtful Conservative   

Pingback from  Waukesha Carnival  « Musings of a Thoughtful Conservative

April 27, 2008 4:51 PM

Leave a Comment

Please Sign In to post comment.

Posts

Tags

How the other half lives

Search the Blogs